Hot tubs have been shown to be associated with disease. A well documented example of this is Hot Tub Lung (Mycobacteria induced respiratory illness) as a result of hot tub use.
Hot tubs are a favorable environment for these thermophillic bacteria and their disinfectant-resistant nature can make them a potential health risk for bathers. Once established, a Mycobacteria infection can also be very difficult to treat with antibiotics. The Center for Biofilm Engineering at Montana State University has developed hot tub simulations to study the efficacy of chlorine as a disinfectant against Mycobacterium fortuitum.
Bacterial samples were taken from three locations: from the bulk water, from coupons mimicking hot tub surfaces such as walls, and from inline hot tub filters. In the control, it was determined that colonies were particularly prevalent in the bulk water and on the inline filters. The main result was that while chlorine worked fairly well in a clean system inoculated with an organism, if fouled filters were moved to a clean system (analogous to a poor cleaning or just a spray down of the filter) with no new inoculation, M. fortuitum would not just survive but would actually GROW in the presence of chlorine. This enhances the chances for a user to experience repeat exposure and eventually develop a Type III Immunopathology response, hypersensitivity pneumonitis.
Chronic hot tub use can lead to inoculation of the bacterium resulting in the development of antibodies circulating in the blood stream. At a certain threshold, an individual may enter the hot tub and develop an immune response to the bacteria, as the circulating antibodies bind to the antigen. When the antibodies bind to the antigen large immune complexes form that cannot be cleared and they are subsequently deposited in vessel walls and there is an inflammatory response.
The center at MSU suggested that hot tub filters are really tricky to effectively clean due to all of the folds and even an aggressive cleaning could result in this occurrence.
All that said and I will be hot tubbing sometime this winter season!
05 December 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
I don't know if that was something I necessarily wanted to know... I love hot tubs!!
That's really interesting. I have heard of people getting skin rashes or reaction to hot tubs, but I didn't know it could get as serious as a lung disorder.
This post brings up a question that has crossed my mind a few times...
What are the properties of antigens that induce type III hypersensitivities (that is immune complexes of 'just the right size')? It seems that infection with any immunogen we have been immunized with is bound to produce complexes of 'just the right size' based on the diffusion rates of antigen and antibody. So, really, is it just the size of these complexes that induce the sensitivity?
In more direct response to the hot tub post, turn off the bubbles and worry less - right?
this is very interesting, but couldn't any regular schedule of cleaning prevent this? also does it matter how long one stays in the hot tub? some people can stay in for hour while others maybe more like 20 min. how long does this take to infect the person? plus some pools and hot tubs use bromine instead of chlorine and i wonder what difference this makes
Thanks for the info. I think inhaling the chlorine fumes could possible be worse. Well, I guess everything in moderation! Outside hot tubs may be better than inside tubs. I also wonder if exposing the filters to sunlight would help reduce bacteria levels in addition to cleaning the filters. Yes, I wonder about bromine!??
This post had now made me think twice about going in the hot tub as much as I do! How common is it really to get a lung disorder from the hot tub? I wonder if this would be more common with people who frequently use the hot tub and stay in for extended periods of time? Also I know some people that does always shower right after the pool or hot tub...I wonder if the chemicals staying on your skin for so long after could also make this worse or lead to this disorder! Very interesting topic!
Wow, this is quite interesting. Though it doesn't surprise me too much. Every time I step into a hot tub I always wonder about the microbes bathing with me and if they are really being killed by the chlorine. With that said, I'm wondering if swimmers in a community pool are less likely to get infections (like a cold or flu) than other athletes.
Post a Comment